Mike Trout vs Mickey Mantle Comparison | Fueled by Sports

Mike Trout vs Mickey Mantle Comparison

Tweet about this on TwitterShare on FacebookPin on PinterestShare on Google+Share on RedditShare on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon

Mike Trout vs Mickey Mantle Comparison (Through Five Seasons)

Head-to-head comparison of MLB Hall of Fame center fielder Mickey Mantle and current big league center fielder Mike Trout that includes stats, World Series, and awards.  This comparison is through four seasons and both players stats will be updated after the 2016 season.  Go to our Player Comparison page to check out other comparisons.

Go here to see an updated comparison.

Team, Position and Height

Team

Mike Trout – Los Angeles Angels
Mickey Mantle – New York Yankees

Position

Mike Trout – Centerfielder
Mickey Mantle – Centerfielder

Height

Mike Trout – 6’2″
Mickey Mantle – 5’11”

Major League Debut Age

Mike Trout – 19 Years Old
Mickey Mantle – 19 Years Old

Years in this Comparison

Mike Trout - 2011-2015
Mickey Mantle – 1951-1955

World Series and Playoff Appearances

World Series 

Mike Trout - 0
Mickey Mantle – 3 (1951-1953) images images images

World Series Appearances

Mike Trout - 0
Mickey Mantle – 4 (1951-1953, 1955) images images images images

Playoff Appearances

Mike Trout - 1 (2014) images
Mickey Mantle – 4 (1951-1953, 1955) images images images images

World Series MVP

Mike Trout - 0
Mickey Mantle – 0 *Award wasn’t introduced until 1955

Awards and Honors

MVP

Mike Trout - 1 (2014) images
Mickey Mantle – 0

Gold Gloves

Mike Trout - 0
Mickey Mantle – *Award wasn’t introduced until 1957

Rookie of the Year

Mike Trout - 1 (2012) images
Mickey Mantle – 0

All-Star Games

Mike Trout - 4 (2012-2015) images images images images
Mickey Mantle – 4 (1952-1955) images images images images

Silver Slugger

Mike Trout - 4 (2012-2015) images images images images
Mickey Mantle – *Award wasn’t introduced until 1980

League RBI Champion

Mike Trout - 1 (2014) images
Mickey Mantle – 0

League Home Run Champion

Mike Trout - 0
Mickey Mantle – 1 (1955) images

League Stolen Base Leader

Mike Trout - 1 (2012) images
Mickey Mantle – 0

League Runs Leader

Mike Trout - 3 (2012-2014) images images images
Mickey Mantle – 1 (1954) images

League Batting Champion

Mike Trout - 0
Mickey Mantle – 0

League Total Bases Leader


Mickey Mantle – 0

Regular Season Stats (Offense)

Games

Mike Trout - 652
Mickey Mantle – 658 images

Batting Average 

Mike Trout - .304 images
Mickey Mantle – .298

At-Bats

Mike Trout - 2,248 images
Mickey Mantle – 2,411

Plate Appearances

Mike Trout - 2,877 images
Mickey Mantle – 2,839

Hits

Mike Trout - 744 images
Mickey Mantle – 719

Runs

Mike Trout - 477
Mickey Mantle – 510 images

Home Runs

Mike Trout - 139 images
Mickey Mantle – 121

RBIs

Mike Trout - 397
Mickey Mantle – 445 images

Stolen Bases

Mike Trout - 113 images
Mickey Mantle – 33

Total Bases

Mike Trout - 1,368 images
Mickey Mantle – 1,272

Walks

Mike Trout - 361
Mickey Mantle – 412 images

Strikeouts

Mike Trout - 647
Mickey Mantle – 479 images

Doubles

Mike Trout - 143 images
Mickey Mantle – 114

Triples

Mike Trout - 32
Mickey Mantle – 38 images

On-base Percentage 

Mike Trout - .397
Mickey Mantle – .400 images

Slugging Percentage

Mike Trout - .559 images
Mickey Mantle – .528

On-Base + Slugging Percentage (OPS)

Mike Trout - .956 images
Mickey Mantle – .928

WAR (Wins Above Replacement)

Mike Trout - 37.9 images
Mickey Mantle – 29.7

OPS+

Mike Trout - 169 images
Mickey Mantle – 155

BABIP

Mike Trout - .357 images
Mickey Mantle – .329

Regular Season Stats (Defense)

Games

Mike Trout - 627
Mickey Mantle – 644 images

Innings

Mike Trout - 5,502 2/3
Mickey Mantle – 5,549 1/3 images

Put Outs

Mike Trout - 1,590 images
Mickey Mantle – 1,524

Assists

Mike Trout - 14
Mickey Mantle – 66 images

Errors

Mike Trout - 11 images
Mickey Mantle – 37

Fielding Percentage

Mike Trout - .993 images
Mickey Mantle – .977

Playoff Stats

Games

Mike Trout - 3


Mickey Mantle – 18 images

Batting Average 

Mike Trout - .083
Mickey Mantle – .265 images

At-Bats

Mike Trout - 12
Mickey Mantle – 68 images

Plate Appearances

Mike Trout - 15
Mickey Mantle – 76 images

Hits

Mike Trout - 1
Mickey Mantle – 18 images

Runs

Mike Trout - 1
Mickey Mantle – 10 images

Home Runs

Mike Trout - 1
Mickey Mantle – 5 images

RBIs

Mike Trout - 1
Mickey Mantle – 11 images

Stolen Bases

Mike Trout - 0
Mickey Mantle – 0

Total Bases

Mike Trout - 4
Mickey Mantle – 36 images

Walks

Mike Trout - 3
Mickey Mantle – 8 images

Strikeouts

Mike Trout - 2 images
Mickey Mantle – 15

Doubles

Mike Trout - 0
Mickey Mantle – 1 images

Triples

Mike Trout - 0
Mickey Mantle – 1 images

On-base Percentage 

Mike Trout - .267
Mickey Mantle – .342 images

Slugging Percentage

Mike Trout - .333
Mickey Mantle – .529 images

On-Base + Slugging Percentage (OPS)

Mike Trout - .600
Mickey Mantle – .871 images

Who do you think is the better player at this point in their career?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Click to comment
To Top