Round:
Round 1
| Pick | Team | Player | Pos | School |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Kansas City Athletics | Rick Monday | OF | Arizona State University |
| 2 | New York Mets | Les Rohr | P | Billings West High School MT) |
| 3 | Washington Senators | Joe Coleman | P | Natick High School (MA) |
| 4 | Houston Astros | Alex Barrett | SS | Atwater High School (CA) |
| 5 | Boston Red Sox | Billy Conigliaro | OF | Swampscott High School (MA) |
| 6 | Chicago Cubs | Rick James | P | Coffee High School (AL) |
| 7 | Cleveland Indians | Ray Fosse | C | Marion High School (IL) |
| 8 | Los Angeles Dodgers | John Wyatt | SS | Bakersfield High School (CA) |
| 9 | Minnesota Twins | Eddie Leon | SS | University of Arizona |
| 10 | Pittsburgh Pirates | Doug Dickerson | OF | Ensley High School (AL) |
| 11 | California Angels | Jim Spencer | 1B | Andover High School (MD) |
| 12 | Milwaukee Braves | Dick Grant | 1B | Watertown High School (MA) |
| 13 | Detroit Tigers | Gene Lamont | C | Hiawatha High School (IL) |
| 14 | San Francisco Giants | Alan Gallagher | 3B | Santa Clara University |
| 15 | Baltimore Orioles | Scott McDonald | P | Marquette High School (WA) |
| 16 | Cincinnati Reds | Bernie Carbo | 3B | Livonia High School (MI) |
| 17 | Chicago White Sox | Ken Plesha | C | University of Notre Dame |
| 18 | Philadelphia Phillies | Mike Adamson | P | Point Loma High School (CA) |
| 19 | New York Yankees | Bill Burbach | P | Wahlert High School (IA) |
| 20 | St. Louis Cardinals | Joe DiFabio | P | Delta State University |