Other Comparisons:
Curt Schilling vs Roy Halladay Comparison
Head-to-head comparison of MLB pitchers Curt Schilling and Roy Halladay that includes stats, World Series, and awards. Go to our Player Comparison page to check out other comparisons.
Team, Position and Height
Teams
Curt Schilling – 5 (Baltimore Orioles, Houston Astros, Philadelphia Phillies, Arizona Diamondbacks, Boston Red Sox)
Roy Halladay – 2 (Toronto Blue Jays, Philadelphia Phillies)
Position
Curt Schilling – Right Handed Pitcher
Roy Halladay – Right Handed Pitcher
Height
Curt Schilling – 6’5″
Roy Halladay – 6’6″
Major League Debut Age
Curt Schilling – 21
Roy Halladay – 21
Seasons Played
Curt Schilling – 20 
Roy Halladay – 16
World Series and Playoff Appearances
World Series
Curt Schilling – 3 (2001, 2004, 2007)
Roy Halladay – 0
World Series Appearances
Curt Schilling – 4 (1993, 2001, 2004, 2007)
Roy Halladay – 0
Playoff Appearances
Curt Schilling – 5 (1993, 2001, 2003, 2004, 2007)
Roy Halladay – 2 (2010, 2011)
World Series MVP
Curt Schilling – 1 (2001)
Roy Halladay – 0
Awards and Honors
Hall of Fame
Curt Schilling – No (Eligible)
Roy Halladay – No (Not Eligible until 2019)
Cy Young Award
Curt Schilling – 0
Roy Halladay – 2 (2003, 2010)
MVP
Curt Schilling – 0
Roy Halladay – 0
Gold Gloves
Curt Schilling – 0
Roy Halladay – 0
Rookie of the Year
Curt Schilling – 0
Roy Halladay – 0
All-Star Games
Curt Schilling – 6 (1997–1999, 2001, 2002, 2004)
Roy Halladay – 8 (2002, 2003, 2005, 2006, 2008–2011)
No Hitters or Perfect Games
Curt Schilling – 0
Roy Halladay – 2 (Perfect Game May 29, 2010 and a postseason no-hitter on October 6, 2010)
League Leader in Wins
Curt Schilling – 2 (2001, 2004)
Roy Halladay – 2 (2003, 2010)
ERA League Leader
Curt Schilling – 0
Roy Halladay – 0
Strikeout League Leader
Curt Schilling – 2 (1997-1998)
Roy Halladay – 0
Complete Game League Leader
Curt Schilling – 4 (1996, 1998, 2000-2001)
Roy Halladay – 7 (2003, 2005, 2007-2011)
Shutouts League Leader
Curt Schilling – 0
Roy Halladay – 4 (2003, 2008-2010)
WHIP League Leader
Curt Schilling – 2 (1992, 2002)
Roy Halladay – 1 (2008)
Regular Season Pitching Stats
Games
Curt Schilling – 569
Roy Halladay – 416
Games Started
Curt Schilling – 436
Roy Halladay – 390
Wins
Curt Schilling – 216
Roy Halladay – 203
Losses
Curt Schilling – 146
Roy Halladay – 105
Win-Loss Percentage
Curt Schilling – .597
Roy Halladay – .659
ERA (Earned Run Average)
Curt Schilling – 3.46
Roy Halladay – 3.38
Strikeouts
Curt Schilling – 3,116
Roy Halladay – 2,117
Innings Pitched
Curt Schilling – 3,261
Roy Halladay – 2,749 1/3
Hits Allowed
Curt Schilling – 2,998
Roy Halladay – 2,646
Earned Runs Allowed
Curt Schilling – 1,253
Roy Halladay – 1,034
Runs Allowed
Curt Schilling – 1,318
Roy Halladay – 1,135
Home Runs Allowed
Curt Schilling – 347
Roy Halladay – 236
WHIP (Walks + Hits/Innings Pitched)
Curt Schilling – 1.14
Roy Halladay – 1.18
Complete Games
Curt Schilling – 83
Roy Halladay – 67
Shutouts
Curt Schilling – 20
Roy Halladay – 20
Batters Faced
Curt Schilling – 13,284
Roy Halladay – 11,287
Walks
Curt Schilling – 711
Roy Halladay – 592
Intentional Walks
Curt Schilling – 43
Roy Halladay – 28
Hit by Pitch
Curt Schilling – 52
Roy Halladay – 81
Balks
Curt Schilling – 8
Roy Halladay – 9
Hits Per 9 Innings
Curt Schilling – 8.3
Roy Halladay – 8.7
Strikeouts Per 9 Innings
Curt Schilling – 8.6
Roy Halladay – 6.9
Home Runs Per 9 Innings
Curt Schilling – 1.0
Roy Halladay – 0.8
Walks Per 9 Innings
Curt Schilling – 2.0
Roy Halladay – 1.9
Defensive Stats
Fielding Percentage
Curt Schilling – .956
Roy Halladay – .976
Defensive Chances
Curt Schilling – 502
Roy Halladay – 633
Putouts
Curt Schilling – 183
Roy Halladay – 228
Assists
Curt Schilling – 297
Roy Halladay – 390
Errors
Curt Schilling – 22
Roy Halladay – 15
Double Plays
Curt Schilling – 19
Roy Halladay – 22
Pickoffs
Curt Schilling – 14
Roy Halladay – 3
Stolen Bases
Curt Schilling – 105
Roy Halladay – 221
Caught Stealing
Curt Schilling – 79
Roy Halladay – 64
Postseason Pitching
Games
Curt Schilling – 19
Roy Halladay – 5
Games Started
Curt Schilling – 19
Roy Halladay – 5
Wins
Curt Schilling – 11
Roy Halladay – 3
Losses
Curt Schilling – 2
Roy Halladay – 2
Win-Loss Percentage
Curt Schilling – .846
Roy Halladay – .600
ERA (Earned Run Average)
Curt Schilling – 2.23
Roy Halladay – 2.37
Strikeouts
Curt Schilling – 120
Roy Halladay – 35
Innings Pitched
Curt Schilling – 133 1/3
Roy Halladay – 38
Hits Allowed
Curt Schilling – 104
Roy Halladay – 23
Earned Runs Allowed
Curt Schilling – 33
Roy Halladay – 10
Runs Allowed
Curt Schilling – 37
Roy Halladay – 10
Home Runs Allowed
Curt Schilling – 12
Roy Halladay – 3
WHIP (Walks + Hits/Innings Pitched)
Curt Schilling – 0.97
Roy Halladay – 0.74
Complete Games
Curt Schilling – 4
Roy Halladay – 1
Shutouts
Curt Schilling – 2
Roy Halladay – 1
Batters Faced
Curt Schilling – 525
Roy Halladay – 143
Walks
Curt Schilling – 25
Roy Halladay – 5
Intentional Walks
Curt Schilling – 0
Roy Halladay – 1
Hit by Pitch
Curt Schilling – 3
Roy Halladay – 0
Balks
Curt Schilling – 0
Roy Halladay – 0
Hits Per 9 Innings
Curt Schilling – 7.0
Roy Halladay – 5.4
Strikeouts Per 9 Innings
Curt Schilling – 8.1
Roy Halladay – 8.3
Home Runs Per 9 Innings
Curt Schilling – 0.8
Roy Halladay – 0.7
Walks Per 9 Innings
Curt Schilling – 1.7
Roy Halladay – 1.2
[poll id=”74″]